Startup Shutdown: The Warning Signs, the Costs, and the Emotional Reckoning
Every startup community has a playbook for launching a company. There are accelerator programs, pitch competitions, fundraising advisers, founder communities, and countless playbooks all exist for getting a company off the ground. And yes, there are plenty of cheerleaders ready to pump up your idea.
But need to shut down that startup? There is far less structure around that moment.
It is a financial decision as much as it is an emotional one, said founders who have been through the experience of closing shop.
There are some warning signs to look out for if you are getting close to needing to shut down, says Florida-based business leader Shan Nair, PhD, president of Nucleus. Declining sales, a management team resistant to change, increasing employee departures, and growing labor disputes as indications that a business may have waited too long to make necessary changes, he told Hypepotamus. These are particularly true of startups that expand internationally too quickly. When several appear at once, they may point to deeper structural problems that require decisive action before a company reaches a crisis point.
Founders in Atlanta, like Judy Price, shared with Hypepotamus her own playbook for shutting down a company. Price ran a charter business in the British Virgin Islands before launching a yacht-focused payments startup. The company bootstrapped with personal savings and support from friends and family. But the team fell into what Price called a classic founder trap: building ahead of validation.
“I threw everything I had into sales calls, market feedback, and product pivots, but the math was clear: the runway to true profitability was just too long. I pulled the metrics together, sat down with my co-founder, and we let the facts decide our next move rather than letting emotion drag out the inevitable,” Price added.
Live Oak Bank's (NYSE: LOB) Venture Banking team provides non-dilutive growth financing that complements equity, along with tailored banking solutions, for venture-backed B2B software and healthcare companies at every stage of their financing journey. We understand entrepreneurs because we are entrepreneurs. Member FDIC
Getting To The Root
The metrics matter in the decision. But so too does the emotional side, said Mark Feinberg, startup coach and entrepreneur-in-residence at HatchBridge.
“[If a founder’s] heart and soul and passion around the idea and the business just isn’t there anymore, then that’s a really good sign” it is time to hang up the idea, Feinberg told Hypepotamus.
That realization can be particularly difficult for entrepreneurs, he added, because it runs counter to the characteristics that often helped them become founders in the first place.
“Founders and entrepreneurs generally are high performers, and giving up on anything is not in our DNA,” Feinberg said.
Getting to the point of accepting that a company is over is a process, he said, and one that often includes genuine grief.
“Grief is on everybody’s schedule individually,” he said, “and how long they process that, and how long they finally allow themselves to make the decision.”
hypepotamus
A Company Needs Runway To Shut Down, Too
Once the decision is made, the harder question follows in figuring out how to shut down. Founders are often encouraged to extend the runway for as long as possible. But Dori Yona, CEO of SimpleClosure, said waiting until the company has almost no money is “one of the biggest mistakes” a company can make.
“Founders often keep pushing because shutting down is an emotional decision, but waiting until the company has almost no cash left can dramatically limit its options,” Yona told Hypepotamus.
A proper wind-down costs money. Companies may still need to cover legal and accounting fees, final tax obligations, employee expenses, regulatory filings, contract terminations, and other costs. Spending the final dollars on one more attempt to save the company can leave founders without the resources needed to close it correctly.
"Shutdown is too important to improvise," Yona said. "It is a consequential business process that deserves a clear plan, accountable ownership, and a higher standard."
Price understood that reality while shutting down her payments startup. Right up until the end, she said, her next move was still focused on finding one last investment check or one creative pivot that could keep the company operating.
“I’m a founder at heart, so I held on as long as humanly possible,” she said.
At the end, Price said she spent her time personally contacting customers who still had transactions in progress that could not be completed through the company’s platform.
“I walked them through alternative payment options and stayed close to them until everything was settled,” she said.
Her approach was built around directness.
“Total honesty and transparency, period,” Price said. “When people trust you with their money, you don’t leave them stranded.”
Price admits she had a safety net to fall back on, which gave her “the headspace to shut things down properly and figure out my next chapter with a clear head.” Now, Price is back in Atlanta serving as the VP of Client Development at Humans Doing, a tech-focused staffing and recruiting company.
That solid next chapter isn’t always the reality. One founder, who asked to not be named in this story, told Hypepotamus that the money associated with paying back a business loan after his company folded caused significant financial hardship. Right now, he’s focused on finding a job outside of tech…and in his words, “far away from the startup life.”
Separating The Founder From The Startup
Once shutdown conversations start, Feinberg said, founders need to separate their identity, and the word "failure,” from the realities of the company. This is something he learned from his own experience building and shutting down a company. And that experience helps him advise founders through different transitions.
“I think we could do a better job of redefining the word [failure]," Feinberg told Hypepotamus. "There's life after a startup…and there are people out there to help you through it."
Helping founders process the end of a company or an idea is so important, it is built into the curriculum at HatchBridge, an incubator program in Kennesaw, Georgia that is under the direction of Director Bill Arnold. For the HatchBridge team, it is about helping founders not only find the wins, but also plan for the path to the next idea, if that is best for the founder.
On A Personal Note…
As a tech and startup reporter, here's something I hear constantly: people want to read more stories about startups shutting down. They want to "true" stories of startups (the good, the bad, and the truly ugly). But ask founders to talk about folding a company, and most don't want to…or they'll only talk once their next startup is up and running.
The startup world runs on talking about success. Founders share highlights in investor updates, on LinkedIn, and in press quotes. But what I consistently hear is that founders want to hear more about the companies that failed, and what those founders learned. Telling that story can be genuinely useful to the broader tech ecosystem. (So reach out if you'd like to chat more about your experience and lessons learned from shutting down your startup).
--
Featured Photo by Tim Mossholder / Unsplash
See more Hypepotamus stories in your search results
